While the live performances on Disc One capture the impressive firepower fans have come to expect from The Smithereens in concert venues, the acoustic renditions on Disc Two offer a different perspective. The songs recorded at New York’s Folk City club in 1985 show the band reinventing material by lowering the volume and putting an emphasis on vocal arrangements. The melancholy “Alone At Midnight,” one of the underrated gems on Especially For You, sounds magnificent in this stark rendition from Folk City.
I mentioned The Beach Boys a few times in my review of Disc One, and the comparison comes to mind again while listening to the aching melody and glorious harmonies of the acoustic “Strangers When We Meet.” Long-time fans will have fun with the Bonus Tracks, especially “Blood And Roses (Voodoo),” which has the band members adding prehistoric grunts to this ominous tune. There’s a pair of rarities in “Mr. Eliminator,” a surf-guitar instrumental that also features drummer Dennis Diken; and the humorous “White Castle Blues.”
A primitive recording of “I Don’t Want To Lose You” from The Smithereens’ first ever club gig back in 1980 bookends nicely with the powerful renditions of “Blood And Roses” and “Time And Time Again” that were performed live in a studio in 2007. Throughout all its tracks, ESP3CIALLY F0R YOU proves The Smithereens’ music hasn’t lost a bit of its allure over the decades.